There’s a reason I haven’t been writing lately. We took a family trip over Labor Day weekend and got a call on the way home that Brad’s grandmother was having emergency surgery. She’s been in the hospital on a ventilator ever since. We spend more time than usual at the hospital and we have family staying with us most nights. Lately, all of our evenings are spent playing catch-up with laundry, housework, bills and, for Brad, homework.
Jill from Charming and Delightful (one of my favorite readers!) nobly offered to take up the slack for me by writing a guest post. I appreciate her so much.
I’ll be back soon. I promise.
Heather
***************************************
I don’t know how long I’ve been reading Heather’s blog and I can’t even remember how I found her, but Blog Blah Blah was one of the first blogs I began reading on a regular basis. And Heather was one of the first “blog personalities” whose life I followed regularly, despite the fact that we probably couldn’t be more different from each other.
You don’t have to read this blog very long to know that Heather wears her heart on her sleeve and is very open with her emotions. She feels things strongly and needs to express those feelings. I, on the other hand, wear my heart safely inside my chest and tend to bottle things up — internalize them, as my therapist recently described.
For me emotions are to be felt, then moved on from. I don’t have much need to discuss them at length or even dwell on them in my own mind. Good experiences are enjoyed while they last, but then it’s back to reality. Bad experiences are to be learned from, but not agonized over. As such, I live my life with no regrets. Any mistakes I have made have brought me to where I am today — which is a pretty good place in the grand scheme of things — so they must have happened for a reason. To say that I regret something implies I’d want to go back and change it, and that is simply not possible. I don’t have a souped up DeLorean or a Way Back Machine to go back and change the past, and if I did, even the bad choices I made usually had some good come from them, so they’re not really all that bad after all.
There is one exception to this rule. And it’s something I have struggled with for six years now. When I got married in November 2001, there was a very important person missing that day and all because of choices I made out of fear and convenience. And that is a decision I truly regret.
My best friend, E, happens to be my ex-boyfriend, who also happens to be gay. He and I dated off and on through college and made a go at a “real” relationship shortly after I graduated. We were as close as two people could be. We had a connection like I’ve never experienced and despite enduring a rather unhealthy relationship for several years, we simply couldn’t “quit” each other.
Ours was an unorthodox relationship in that even when we called each other boyfriend and girlfriend, neither of us considered the relationship exclusive. There was also the minor detail of E’s bi-sexuality, which basically went undiscussed. In my mind I justified it, I think, by convincing myself that if he wanted to be gay, he would be, but he obviously didn’t and I’d do anything to make him happy. So I stayed with him despite the rumors and secrets. And because he was my best friend. I couldn’t imagine not having him in my life, so I swept the feelings of pain and uncertainty under the proverbial rug.
After nearly five years “together,” I was ready to take the relationship more seriously. We were living in different cities at the time, about an hour and a half apart. The long distance thing was wearing on me physically and mentally. Truth be told, I didn’t trust him and was suspicious of where he was and who he was with when we were apart. I was living in Milwaukee at the time and E was in Chicago, which offered more opportunities to me professionally. It seemed to make sense that I move to Chicago — so we could take our relationship and my career to the next level.
When I brought it up, he balked. And after much discussion he admitted that he didn’t think our relationship would be the same if we lived together — or even in the same city. And he was right. And that was my point. I was ready for a change, but he was satisfied with the status quo because of the internal struggles he was facing regarding his feelings for me and the other feelings he had been denying for so many years. I didn’t realize this at the time, but I believe it to be true now.
We ended up breaking up. It was more painful than anything I had gone through at the time. And I swore off dating, not only because I was still getting over E, but because I didn’t really know how to date. We had been together, such as it was, for so long, but I never really dated him or anyone else in the traditional sense of the word. I didn’t even know where to start. I was particularly not interested in having another long-term relationship, so when a friend from work offered to introduce me to a friend of hers visiting from Chicago I was absolutely not interested. “The last thing I need is to date another guy from Chicago,” were my exact words, I believe. But for some reason, I went along with her one night after work and met this guy. And it was like being struck by lightning. I wanted to see him again and when I did, I wanted to keep seeing him.
Going to visit this new guy in Chicago opened up the possibility that I would run into E, and I didn’t want it to be a total shock if it happened, so I called him to tell him that I was seeing someone new. To say he didn’t take it well would be an understatement. Not necessarily because he wanted me back, but I think he must have been going through a very difficult time as he struggled with his sexual identity. And the last thing he needed was to hear that I had found someone… someone he was convinced, somehow, was the one. It was just too much for him to handle and he took his frustrations and emotions out on me. It was not pretty and I decided I didn’t need that kind of drama in my life, so I walked away from the whole situation. Wrote him out of my life.
Fast forward 3 or so years. I am living in Chicago and engaged to the “guy from Chicago.” I have a great job and we are planning a perfectly beautiful wedding for the fall. But something is missing. There is a hole in my life and there’s only one thing that can make me complete. I look up E online and send an email to an address I recognize from when we were together. I don’t know if it’s still active, but it’s the best way I know to reach out to him. In my email, I say that I’ve been thinking about him a lot and find that has time goes on, I miss him more and more. He responds quickly and tells me he has been wanting to reach out to me too, but didn’t know if I would be receptive to him. We decide to meet for drinks one evening after work to catch up.
E has something he wants to tell me. Something very important. He doesn’t tell me this, but I know it. Because a year or so earlier a mutual friend of ours outed him to me. Walking into the bar that evening, though, he didn’t realize I already knew, and was visibly nervous. We were there, catching up, for quite a while, but he still hadn’t shared his news with me. I excused myself to the restroom and told myself that if we walked out of there that night and he hadn’t told me he was gay it meant that he didn’t value our relationship and I would be done with him. It turned out to be one of the first things he said when I returned to the table. And I hadn’t realized it until then, but I had a choice to make. Do I tell him that I already know or do I feign surprise? I knew I couldn’t fake my reaction, so when he said, “I’m gay,” I simply said, “I know.” We talked about how I found out and a hundred other things before we headed home that evening, and we kept in touch via email and instant messenger, with an occasional dinner or night out on the town.
It was as if no time had passed at all. And we had our “friend” — the one who prematurely outed him — to thank for that. While E would have preferred to be the one to tell me personally, having his secret revealed by someone else was a blessing in disguise as it gave me the time to absorb it and come to terms with it. We jumped back into our friendship with a better understanding of what went wrong in our relationship and were both in good places personally, so the bad stuff just didn’t matter. As I said at the time “A lot of things make sense now.”
When it came time to send out invitations to my wedding, several months had passed since I reconnected with E (and Hubbz certainly wasn’t threatened by my gay ex-boyfriend), so we happily added him to our list. He was thrilled to receive the invitation but wanted to make sure his attendance wouldn’t cause any problems for me or my family. They had met E on several occasions when we were together. He even stayed at my parents’ house with me and met my grandparents and extended family. And I didn’t think about it initially, but it did present a conundrum. How to explain the presence of my ex-boyfriend to my conservative Midwest family? My parents didn’t even know that he and I had reconnected because the questions about “What does Hubbz think of that?” would lead to the inevitable revelation that he was gay, and I didn’t know how to deal with that. It would take a lot of explaining. And I would have to answer a lot of questions. People might be uncomfortable, too. It was just too much to absorb and deal with at the time, with the other wedding details I had to take care of, so I simply just ignored the issue, hoping it would go away. Which it did. E voluntarily opted out of attending the wedding, even though we both wanted nothing more than share the day together.
We had been through so much together. He knew me when I was a 19-year-old small town girl unsure of herself and what she could accomplish in life. Your wedding day is one of the defining moments where you want everyone important to you to be around you, so you can take it all in and revel in how far you’ve come and what bright things lie ahead. And because I was too scared to confront a delicate subject with my family one of the most important people wouldn’t be there. And it broke my heart.
This fall, Hubbz and I celebrate our sixth wedding anniversary and to this day, I am so disappointed in myself and my cowardice in not proudly presenting E, not as my gay ex-boyfriend, but as my best friend, to my family. I can make excuses about how busy I was, how much other stress I was under, until I’m blue in the face, but it doesn’t change the fact that I let fear trump friendship. I know it hurt him at the time and knowing that makes it even harder to accept what I did. Which was essentially nothing, but that doing nothing is something I truly wish I could go back and change. Maybe it wouldn’t have gone well, maybe he still wouldn’t have come, but I would have put my own discomfort aside for the sake of our friendship, and that would have been something.